To be useful, learning requires memory, so what we’ve learned is still there later when we need it.
Peter C. Brown
The meaning of the quote
Early in his career, pilot Matt Brown was flying a twin-engine Cessna northeast out of Harlingen, Texas, when the oil pressure in his right engine dropped.
There was no time to look anything up. Everything he knew about the plane’s limits had to come out of his head, right then, at 11,000 feet. He shut the engine down and brought the plane in on wide left-hand turns to keep enough lift to land.
Peter C. Brown and his co-authors open the book Make It Stick with that story because it shows what the quote means. Learning you can’t call up when it matters hasn’t done its job. Think of the formula you crammed and lost 2 days after the exam, or the language you studied for 3 years and still can’t order lunch in.
Most of us study by rereading and highlighting half the page. It all starts to look familiar, and familiar feels like knowing. The authors call this an illusion of knowing. Then the exam asks you to produce the answer from a blank page, and recognizing something is a different skill from recalling it.
The book’s answer, backed by research, is retrieval practice, which means pulling information out of your memory instead of pouring it back in. One short quiz after reading a text helps you remember more than reading the text again. Brown sums it up in 10 words.
“Get it out to get it in and make it stick.”
Peter C. Brown, in an interview with Lecturio
Mary Pat Wentworth, a biology professor at the University of Washington, gives her students a picture for it. She tells them a memory sits somewhere in a forest. Each time you find your way to it without help, you wear the path a little deeper, and grabbing your notes too soon skips the walk.
Pilots train the same way. They rehearse engine trouble in simulators again and again, so the steps come back on their own when a real gauge starts to drop.
Action steps
So the way you study should make you pull answers out of your own head. These 4 habits help.
- Close the book and write what you remember.
After a chapter or a class, give yourself 5 minutes with a blank page. Then open the book and check what you missed. - Quiz yourself instead of rereading.
Turn each heading into a question or make flashcards. Answer first, then check. - Come back after a few days.
Test yourself again after 1 day, then after a week. It feels harder because you’ve forgotten a little, and that effort is what makes it last. Psychologists call this the spacing effect, a principle Hermann Ebbinghaus helped uncover more than a century ago. - Practice the way you’ll use it.
If you need it for an exam, answer practice questions with the book shut and a timer on. If it’s a presentation, say it out loud.
Learning that only lives on the page can’t help you at 11,000 feet.
About the author
Peter C. Brown spent his working life as a management consultant, with a degree in English literature and no training in science.
About 20 years before Make It Stick, he took a fiction course in Minneapolis. In the podcast Cult of Pedagogy, he said he wrote one short story after another so he could learn from his mistakes quickly.
In 2006 he published his first novel, The Fugitive Wife, about a Midwestern farm woman who heads north in the 1900 Nome gold rush in Alaska. His grandfather had been an engineer for a gold-mining company in Nome. Brown never met him, but his grandfather’s diaries and scrapbooks fed the story.
His brother-in-law, Henry “Roddy” Roediger, is a cognitive psychologist at Washington University in St. Louis. Roediger and his colleague Mark McDaniel were wrapping up 10 years of research on how people learn, and they wanted ordinary readers to hear about it. They asked Brown to tell it through stories.
The scientists first planned to split the chapters between them, the way academics usually do. Brown pushed back and offered to write the drafts himself so the book would speak in one voice. He worked through the research like a student, put it in his own words and then let the scientists check it.
Make It Stick came out in 2014 from Harvard University Press and became an international bestseller, written by a novelist with no science degree.
You can find the quote in the first chapter of Make It Stick, a few pages after Matt Brown’s oil pressure drops.
Resources
- Make It Stick by Peter C. Brown (Book summary)
- Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning (Book)
- Make It Stick with Peter Brown, The Art of Manliness #385 (Podcast)
- The Science of Successful Learning Habits, Modern Wisdom #24 (Podcast)
- Cult of Pedagogy Episode 21 with Peter Brown (Podcast)
- Make It Stick chapter summaries and downloads (Website)
- 2 Evidence-Based Learning Strategies (Article)
- Testing effect (Wikipedia)



Leave feedback about this