Memory is everything. Without it we are nothing.
Eric Kandel
The meaning of the quote
In 1985, a British conductor named Clive Wearing caught a virus that destroyed the part of his brain that turns new experiences into lasting memories. Since then, his memory for events has lasted somewhere between 7 and 30 seconds.
His carers gave him a diary, and he filled page after page with lines like this one:
“8:31 AM: Now I am really, completely awake.”
Minutes later, he would cross the entry out, because he had no memory of writing it.
What Clive lost is what neuroscientist Eric Kandel described at a 2014 meeting of psychiatrists in New York:
“Without memory, each moment in life is an isolated fragment.”
Yet Clive can still play complex pieces on the piano and conduct a choir. When his wife Deborah walks into the room, he greets her with joy, often believing he hasn’t seen her in years. She later said:
“Clive had lost all that and yet he was still Clive.”
The brain keeps more than one kind of memory. Facts and events are stored in one system, while skills like playing the piano are stored in another, called procedural memory. Clive lost his story but kept his music and his love for Deborah.
Even the parts of Clive that survived were memories.
Kandel won his Nobel Prize for showing that memory is physical. When you learn something, the connections between your nerve cells grow stronger, and when a memory lasts, the brain builds brand-new connections.
Action steps:
Build lasting memories
You can’t choose everything you remember, but you can help your brain keep the parts you care about.
- Spread out your practice.
In sea slug experiments, 4 or 5 lessons spaced out over time built a long-term memory, while the same lessons crammed together didn’t. Go over anything you want to keep the next day, then 3 days later, then a week later. - Save the stories you’d hate to lose.
This week, ask a parent or grandparent to tell you one story from their childhood and record it on your phone. Their memories are part of who they are.
Clive Wearing starts over every 30 seconds. Your memories carry over from one day to the next, so choose what you repeat.
About the author
On November 9, 1938, two days after his 9th birthday, Eric Kandel was steering a new blue toy car around his family’s apartment in Vienna when Nazi police pounded on the door. The Kandels were Jewish, and that night became known as Kristallnacht.
In 1939, the family escaped to Brooklyn, New York. The memory of that night stayed with Kandel, and it later drew him to the question of how the brain holds on to an experience.
He studied history and literature at Harvard, where his girlfriend Anna Kris introduced him to Freud. He switched to medicine to become a psychoanalyst.
Then he made a move his colleagues saw as career suicide. He set out to study memory in a sea slug called Aplysia, which has only about 20,000 nerve cells, some big enough to see without a microscope.
The bet paid off in 2000, when Kandel shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Arvid Carlsson and Paul Greengard.
Many of the calls came from Vienna, celebrating another Austrian Nobel Prize. Austria’s president, Thomas Klestil, wrote to ask how the country could honour him. Kandel turned down the usual ceremonies and asked Austria to face its Nazi past instead, and in 2003 the University of Vienna held a symposium on exactly that.
A man who had spent his life studying memory was asking his home country to remember.
Kandel tells his whole story in the book In Search of Memory. In the documentary In Search of Memory, director Petra Seeger takes him back to the Vienna he fled as a boy, and that film is where he says the quote.
Resources
- In Search of Memory by Eric Kandel (Book)
- In Search of Memory by Petra Seeger (Video)
- Nobel Prize Talks: Eric R. Kandel (Podcast)
- Eric Kandel Reminisces About Memory on NPR’s Science Friday (Podcast)
- Eric Kandel: From Mind to Brain and Back Again (Article)
- Clive Wearing (Wikipedia)
- Forever Today by Deborah Wearing (Book)



Leave feedback about this