Learn all your life. Learn from your failures. Learn from your successes. When you hit a spell of trouble, ask “What is it trying to teach me?” The lessons aren’t always happy ones, but they keep coming.
John W. Gardner
The meaning of the quote
On November 10, 1990, a white-haired 78-year-old stood in front of a room of McKinsey & Company consultants in Phoenix, Arizona, and told them he had started a new job after his 77th birthday.
The speaker was John W. Gardner.
In that Personal Renewal speech, Gardner’s point was that school ends but learning shouldn’t. Every result, good or bad, has a lesson in it, and you only find it if you look.
Learn from failures
Sara Blakely, the founder of Spanx, grew up with a father who asked an odd question at the dinner table.
“We’d sit around the dinner table and he’d ask, ‘What did you guys fail at this week?’ If we had nothing to tell him, he’d be disappointed.”
Her father wanted his kids to keep trying, so failing was normal in that house. Years later, Blakely sold fax machines door to door, where people slammed doors in her face and ripped up her business cards. She learned to take a no and keep going, and she used that lesson when she pitched Spanx, started with $5,000 of her savings, to major retailers.
Learn from successes
Success is harder to learn from, because people rarely stop to study a win. Bill Gates warned about this in his 1995 book The Road Ahead, written while Microsoft ruled the software world.
“Success is a lousy teacher. It seduces smart people into thinking they can’t lose.”
When something goes well, ask why. Maybe you aced the exam because you tested yourself every night for a week, or maybe the questions happened to be easy. If you know which, you can repeat the win. If you don’t, you’re counting on luck to show up again.
Ask the question
The question gives you a job to do while the trouble lasts, which is to find something you can use.
He was honest that the answers can sting. A lost job might teach you that you stopped growing in it years ago. A friendship that fades might show you that you quit calling first. Neither lesson is fun to hear, but you can act on both.
Exercise:
Which lesson are you missing?
Gardner’s question works on any result, so test it on 3 from your own life.
- Pick your last failure. Ask what it was trying to teach you and write the answer in one sentence. If your answer is “nothing,” keep asking until you find something you’d do differently next time.
- Pick your last success. Write down why it worked. If you can’t explain it, you can’t count on doing it again.
- Pick the trouble you’re in right now. Ask Gardner’s question before you ask how to get out of it. The answer often points to the way out.
Look at your 3 answers. The one you found hardest to write is probably the part of the quote you’ve been skipping.
The lessons keep coming either way. You get to decide whether you learn them the first time or wait for the repeat.
About the author
John W. Gardner (1912–2002) lost his father before he turned 1. His mother, Marie, raised him and sold houses in a small rural village surrounded by lima bean farms.
The village was Beverly Hills.
Gardner studied psychology at Stanford and earned a PhD from the University of California, Berkeley, in 1938. By 1955 he was president of the Carnegie Corporation, and he went on to write Excellence and Self-Renewal, 2 books about how people and organizations keep learning instead of going stale.
In 1965, President Lyndon Johnson asked Gardner to run the Department of Health, Education and Welfare. He was the only Republican in Johnson’s cabinet, and his department launched Medicare.
In 1968 he resigned because he couldn’t support the war in Vietnam.
He came out of that spell of trouble with a new idea. Washington was full of organized interest groups, but ordinary citizens had no lobby of their own. In 1970 he founded Common Cause, which signed up 100,000 members in 23 weeks. He summed up the idea in a 1972 speech.
“Everybody’s organized but the people. Now it’s the citizens’ turn.”
People started calling him “the father of campaign finance reform.”
In 1990, 20 years after founding Common Cause, Gardner was still learning at 78, and that’s what he told the consultants in Phoenix. You can read the full Personal Renewal speech on PBS, where you’ll find this quote alongside his thoughts on meaning, commitment and staying curious past middle age.
Resources
- Personal Renewal (Article)
- Self-Renewal: The Individual and the Innovative Society (Book)
- John Gardner: Uncommon American (Website)
- John W. Gardner (Wikipedia)
- The Road Ahead (Book)
- Spanx CEO Sara Blakely on fear and success (Article)



Leave feedback about this